Here's the slippery dichotomy:
The virus is real ...
A large part of the response and the resultant policy is a work.
You'd really love to live in a world where more people understood this and accepted it as a reality, but that's not the world we live in.
For them ... it's "either/or".
That's the polarizing danger, not the microbe itself.
The fact we have people who believe that politicians, regardless of which side of the aisle they belong, act benevolently and solely for the well-being of their constituents, is proof that mental illness and "Lemming-itis" is the greatest threat to Western civ.
Naturally, I will lean towards quarantining the immunocompromised (elderly, pre-existing conditions, etc.) providing employment protection for those who want to stay home, and allow those who
WANT to return to work and enjoy their liberty to do so.
The current path is riskier than the latter for the NUMEROUS calamities it will usher in. The myopic among us cannot see that. Must be a real hoot to be so purblind.
Final verdict ... our species once again disappoints.