Separation of Church and State is very much so a tenant of our Constitution.
Morality encompasses a sense of ones relationship to their spiritual consciousness, but it also encompasses ones relationship to others. Teaching America should be independent from teaching ANY religious doctorine.
Christian schools are not horrible institutions, imo. But they fail to help create truly American citizens. Other forms of private schools (that do not adhere to regilous doctorine) are usually very efficient. When a school has admission abilities, better funding, technology and faculty they will surely be more efficient on the average. However, I feel they can lack a social diversity, due to financial restraints. Vouchers might seek to remedy that deficiency. But let's be honest....the voucher system will, in time, create many more Christian based schools (exactly what you would advocate for), there will be non-religious private schools as well, but admission requirements would become more strenuous as the number of applications increase. Charter schools would provide a option, but would be subject to funding motivations as well, which would create a desire to select a charter that can be efficient (this would be done almost always along socioeconomic lines). And this would leave even more underfunded schools for the students whose parents choose not to allow their child's education to be dilluted by religious doctrine, and parents who cannot afford to live within the areas that efficient Charter schools cover or who do not have the financial ability to provide tuition, transportation, or both.
As for the efficiency of Public schools? Eliminate tenure, pay more, get more teachers to lower class size, help parents be more involved, and take academics as seriously as we do athletics.....and watch the efficiency increase.
Selectivity and choice boomer are important to freely functioning people. You chose how to educate your kids. You chose where to live. You chose what to eat.You choose what to wear. You have freedoms to make those choices for yourself and your Family.
We have choice as a fundamental right, even the right to chose not to believe.
My biggest problem with Public education is it does not provide Freedom of choice, there is no competition. (read the Public school Teacher's article I posted earlier in this thread)
Your assumptions about the dangers of Private education, school choice vouchers, and the rest of your concerns voiced about Private education remove the one variable that remains constant and in fact is an enhancement to our Liberty.
Our diversity, and Freedom of choice because of it.
I am not concerned about varying levels of quality education among the various choices Parents given competition and Freedom will make because my only prerequisite is that they be given that choice to chose that level of excellence in their educational selections that fit them.
I refuse to believe the Public education model is our only answer because our evidence is that it's "one size fits all" approach does not work. Can not work!
Why?
Because it is not geared to individual needs as much as it is focused on collectivism for the masses to normalize all so individuality is not emphasized.
Private and charter schools are set up on an entirely different paradigm, where individual needs are both addressed and serviced. The good schools fulfilling their missions will grow and multiply, the poor ones will close due to lack of support. That dynamic does not happen in the Public school Government run model.
This is the essence of excellent education, and diversity among that mission is not something we should fear but encourage.
That (diversity) is the advantage we have as a nation living in Freedom and Liberty. Including the freedom to educate our kids Religiously, Spiritually, even humanistically if that is the desire of the Parents.
The point is to place Parents and educators into that primary role of deciding that level of educational emphasis, and not to set up a huge inefficient bureaucracy as a substitute that stunts both moral instruction, individuality, and excellence through pursuit of both.
Last edited: