Of course, neither Trump nor any of his associates have any business dealings with Russia.
03/14/2017 07:00 am ET | Updated 1 day ago
Everything We Know About Trumpland’s Ties To Russia, From Start To Finish
It’s a convoluted history that raises a lot of questions.
By Nick Wing
What’s up with Donald Trump and Russia?
Depending on whom you ask, the answer to that question is either absolutely nothing or a scandal so huge it will lead to the president’s impeachment. So far, it’s unclear if either side is right. The truth may lie somewhere between the two extremes.
Trump’s camp has maintained that contact between the campaign and Russia was inconsequential and in some cases nonexistent, a claim that has proved untrue. We now know that members of Trump’s campaign met with Russian officials as the nation was apparently meddling in the U.S. presidential election with the goal of helping Trump win. If there’s any evidence of collusion between the president or his associates and Russia, however, it hasn’t been released.
Our timeline documents 30 years of Trump and his circle’s connections to Russia, which entered the spotlight in 2015 with the assembly of a campaign staff and platform that showed unprecedented levels of friendliness toward a historical adversary of the United States. The House Intelligence Committee will hold its first public hearing on the matter next week, which will hopefully provide further clarity about what all of this means, if anything.
1987
Trump makes his first documented trip to Russia ― then the Soviet Union ― where he explores expanding his hotel business in Moscow.
That same year, Trump outlines a plan to solve the issue of nuclear proliferation amid Cold War tensions. The solution, he tells journalist Ron Rosenbaum, is for the U.S. and the Soviet Union to join forces and use their nuclear and economic power to keep other nations from developing nukes and more broadly impose their will on the rest of the world.
“Most of those [pre-nuclear] countries are in one form or another dominated by the U.S. and the Soviet Union,” Trump says. “Between those two nations you have the power to dominate any of those countries. So we should use our power of economic retaliation and they use their powers of retaliation and between the two of us we will prevent the problem from happening.”
Ron Galella via Getty Images
Donald Trump celebrates publication of The Art of the Deal at the Trump Tower Atrium in New York City on Dec. 12, 1987. Earlier that year, he made his first reported trip to the Soviet Union and later outlined a U.S.-Russia plan on nuclear proliferation.
1988
Trump plans to meet with Mikhail Gorbachev in New York when the leader of the Soviet Union visits the United Nations. Trump reportedly wants"}}">reportedly wants to pitch his vision of a U.S.-Soviet nuclear alliance to Gorbachev.
Amid murmurs of Gorbachev’s scheduled trip to Trump Tower, Trump explains"}}">explains that his real estate prospects in Moscow didn’t work out.
“In the Soviet Union, you don’t own anything,” he says. “It’s hard to conjure up spending hundreds of millions of dollars on something and not own it.”
The meeting between Trump and Gorbachev ultimately falls through.
1996-1997
Trump resumes plans to expand his real estate empire in Moscow. Despite making several trips to the Russian capital, the project again fails to launch.
2005
Trump agrees to a licensing deal with development company Bayrock to build a hotel in Moscow. Bayrock’s founder is Tevfik Arif, a Kazakhstan-born former Soviet official. Trump reportedly puts Felix Sater"}}">reportedly puts Felix Sater, a Russian-born convicted felon with Mafia ties who now lives in the U.S., in charge of the project.
2006
Two of Trump’s children, Donald Trump Jr. and Ivanka, visit Moscow to meet with potential business partners. Sater claims Trump asked him to accompany"}}">asked him to accompany his children on the trip from New York to Russia, but the Trump Organization later said it was a coincidence that they were in Russia at the same time.
Over the next decade"}}">decade and beyond"}}">beyond, Trump attempts to distance himself from Sater, despite documents suggesting"}}">documents suggesting he played a substantial role at Trump Tower, including serving as a “senior adviser” to Trump.
Steve Carrera / Reuters
Donald Trump Jr., with his father and sister Ivanka, speaks to the press in Chicago on May 10, 2006, about plans for a Trump hotel and tower in Chicago. Donald Trump Jr. and Ivanka traveled to Moscow in 2006 to meet with potential business partners.
2007
Oct. 15 ― Trump praises Russian President Vladimir Putin in an interview with Larry King"}}">interview with Larry King.
“Look at Putin ― what he’s doing with Russia ― I mean, you know, what’s going on over there. I mean this guy has done ― whether you like him or don’t like him ― he’s doing a great job … in rebuilding the image of Russia and also rebuilding Russia period. Forget about image.”
Weeks before Trump’s comments, Putin had made a controversial play to maintain power by becoming Russia’s prime minister after serving two terms as president. He was elected president again in 2012.
2008
In July ― Trump sells a Palm Beach, Florida, estate to Russian oligarch Dmitry Rybolovlev for nearly $100 million. Trump had purchased in 2004 for less than half of that at a bankruptcy auction.
Sept. 15 ― Donald Trump Jr. tells a travel industry publication"}}">tells a travel industry publication that his organization has significant financial ties to Russia, which had led him to make at least a half-dozen trips there over the preceding 18 months.
“In terms of high-end product influx into the U.S., Russians make up a pretty disproportionate cross-section of a lot of our assets,” he says. “We see a lot of money pouring in from Russia. There’s indeed a lot of money coming for new-builds and resale reflecting a trend in the Russian economy and, of course, the weak dollar versus the ruble.”
But Trump’s son admits it’s been hard for them to get a foothold in the Russian market.
“As much as we want to take our business over there, Russia is just a different world,” he says. “t is a question of who knows who, whose brother is paying off who, etc. … It really is a scary place.”
2010
Oct. 26 ― Julian Assange of WikiLeaks teases a large-scale document dump"}}">teases a large-scale document dump supposedly detailing the shadowy inner workings of the Russian government. The release never happens.
Dec. 12 ― During an impromptu chat with Brian Kilmeade of Fox News, Trump calls WikiLeaks “disgraceful”"}}">calls WikiLeaks “disgraceful” and suggests there should be a “death penalty or something” for the perpetrators.
2011
Dec. 5 ― Trump expresses “respect” for Putin in his book Time to Get Tough.
“Putin has big plans for Russia. He wants to edge out its neighbors so that Russia can dominate oil supplies to all of Europe. Putin has also announced his grand vision: the creation of a ‘Eurasian Union’ made up of former Soviet nations that can dominate the region. I respect Putin and the Russians but cannot believe our leader allows them to get away with so much...Hats off to the Russians...[President Barack] Obama’s plan to have Russia stand up to Iran was a horrible failure that turned America into a laughingstock.”
2013
June 18 ― Trump tweets about the upcoming Miss Universe Pageant, which he owns:
Then he tries to make a playdate with Putin:
In August ― The editor-in-chief of the Kremlin-backed RT network reportedly visits Assange at the Ecuadorian Embassy in London, according to a report later released by U.S. intelligence agencies.
“They discussed renewing his broadcast contract with RT, according to Russian and Western media,” the 2017 report states. “Russian media subsequently announced that RT had become ‘the only Russian media company’ to partner with WikiLeaks and had received access to ‘new leaks of secret information.’ RT routinely gives Assange sympathetic coverage and provides him a platform to denounce the United States.”
Oct. 17 ― Trump tells late-night talk show host David Letterman that he has “a lot of business with the Russians.” He responds to Letterman’s quip about Russians being “commies” by calling them “smart” and “tough.” Trump says he had met Putin “once.”
Nov. 10 ― Trump returns from the Miss Universe Pageant, which was apparently an eye-opening trip.
He later tweets"}}">tweets that he plans to build a Trump Tower in Moscow.
2014
In February ― Troops aligned with Russia begin to invade and seize control of the Crimean peninsula in Ukraine.
March 17 ― After Putin officially annexes Crimea, Obama’s administration imposes personal sanctions on Russian officials for facilitating the incursion. Targeted individuals are banned from traveling to the U.S., and their U.S.-based financial assets are frozen.
Throughout 2014 ― Trump grants interviews to biographer Michael D’Antonio, who would go on to write The Truth About Trump. Trump brags about courting Russian clients to buy real estate at his properties in the U.S.
“I know the Russians better than anybody,” Trump tells D’Antonio, according to transcripts the author later provided to The New York Times.
2015
Feb. 25 ― Trump tells conservative radio host Hugh Hewitt he’ll release his tax returns"}}">he’ll release his tax returns if he decides to run for president.
“I would certainly show tax returns if it was necessary,” he says. “I have no objection to certainly showing tax returns.”
Trump never makes this disclosure, which experts say"}}">experts say would provide some clarity about the nature of his dealings in Russia.
June 16 ― Trump officially announces his bid for president.
July 20 ― Trump predicts"}}">predicts that he’d “get along very well with” Putin. Trump also notes that he’d had “major business” in Russia in the past and claims he’d “had a great relationship with the people of Russia.”
Sept. 20 ― Trump says he’s open to meeting"}}">open to meeting with Putin at the United Nations General Assembly. A few days earlier, the Trump Organization’s vice president, Michael Cohen, said it was a “better than likely chance” the two men would convene. A meeting is never confirmed.
Sept. 21 ― Trump describes his 2013 visit to Moscow"}}">describes his 2013 visit to Moscow in an interview with Hugh Hewitt.
“I was with the top-level people, both oligarchs and generals, and top-of-the-government people,” Trump says. “I can’t go further than that, but I will tell you that I met the top people, and the relationship was extraordinary. And we just don’t have relationships in this country. You know, relationship is very important, whether it’s congressmen or whether it’s senators, or, you know, whatever it may be. Relationship is a very important element, and we don’t have it in this country anymore.”
Sept. 29 ― Trump offers kind words to Putin"}}">offers kind words to Putin, telling Fox News’ Bill O’Reilly that the Russian president “is a nicer person than I am.”
Trump also claims Putin is a more effective leader than Obama.
“I will tell you that, in terms of leadership, he’s getting an A and our president is not doing so well,” he says.
Oct. 11 ― Trump continues to portray himself as a friend and acquaintance of Putin.
“I think the biggest thing we have is that we were on ‘60 Minutes’ together and we had fantastic ratings. One of your best-rated shows in a long time,” he jokes on CBS. “So that was good, right? So we were stable mates.”
Nov. 10 ― Trump repeats his claim about Putin and “60 Minutes” at a GOP debate but later clarifies that they never actually met during the taping of the show. Over the next few months, the Trump-Putin bromance continues to blossom, with both men regularly complimenting each other in public comments and appearances.
Dec. 10 ― Retired Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn, former director of the Defense Intelligence Agency, attends a high-profile gala"}}">attends a high-profile gala in Moscow hosted by RT. He’s reportedly paid $40,000 for the appearance, at which he sits near Putin.
Sputnik Photo Agency / Reuters
Retired Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn, left, sits with Russian President Vladimir Putin at an exhibition marking the 10th anniversary of the RT television channel in Moscow on Dec. 10, 2015.
2016
Feb. 9 ― Rex Tillerson, then-CEO of Exxon Mobil, in a speech"}}">in a speech at the University of Texas at Austin, says he has “a very close relationship” with Putin. Less than a year later, Tillerson is confirmed as Trump’s secretary of state.
March 21 ― Trump names Carter Page"}}">names Carter Page as a member of his campaign’s foreign policy team. Page is a former investment banker once based in Moscow and reportedly has ties to Russian energy magnates.
March 28 ― Trump brings on Paul Manafort as campaign manager to help him wrangle delegates in the GOP primary. Manafort had most recently served for more than a decade as senior adviser to former Ukrainian President Viktor F. Yanukovych, a Putin sympathizer who was ousted in 2014 and fled to Russia.
In April ― Manafort reportedly meets"}}">reportedly meets with Konstantin Kilimnik, a joint Russian-Ukrainian citizen who formerly worked as Manafort’s staffer in Washington, D.C. Kilimnik has suspected ties"}}">suspected ties to Russian intelligence officials.
April 27 ― Trump meets Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak before a foreign policy speech in Washington, D.C. Organizers claim the conversation between the two men was brief"}}">the conversation between the two men was brief and perhaps little more than a greeting. Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-Ala.), then a Trump campaign surrogate, reportedly also crosses paths with Kislyak"}}">crosses paths with Kislyak, though it’s unclear if they speak directly.
June 15 ― A hacker or hacker collective known as Guccifer 2.0 releases the first round of documents stolen from the Democratic National Committee. U.S. intelligence agencies later conclude that Russian-directed hackers are behind Guccifer’s actions.
July 7 ― Page delivers a speech at Moscow’s New Economic School criticizing U.S. policy toward Russia as reminiscent of Cold War tactics. He accuses the West of having a “hypocritical focus on ideas such as democratization, inequality, corruption and regime change.” The Trump campaign reportedly approves the trip"}}">reportedly approves the trip, which Page says he took as a private citizen.
An explosive, though unverified, intelligence dossier later claims that during the trip Igor Sechin, CEO of Rosneft, Russia’s state oil company, offers Page and associates a 19 percent stake in the company if he could help lift U.S. sanctions on Russia.
Pushing back against reports"}}">reports that he met with Putin confidants Sechin and Igor Diveykin, the Kremlin’s deputy chief of internal policy, Page says he had no contact with “sanctioned individuals.” He also denies discussing lifting economic sanctions or any further cooperation between the Russian government and the Trump campaign.
Sergei Karpukhin / Reuters
Carter Page, a member of the Trump campaign’s foreign policy team, delivers a speech in Moscow in 2016 in which he criticizes U.S. policy toward Russia.
July 18 ― Delegates at the Republican National Convenction adopt a party platform with wording supporting Ukraine’s sovereignty. Trump staffers reportedly work behind the scenes"}}">reportedly work behind the scenes to water down language that had called for “providing lethal defensive weapons” to Ukrainians and instead offer an amendment calling for the granting of “appropriate assistance.”
Trump national security adviser J.D. Gordon later says he advocated"}}">says he advocated for the softer platform language, which he says was consistent with Trump’s views on the matter.
July 20 ― Trump national security advisers Gordon, Page and Walid Phares reportedly attend a diplomacy event during the Republican National Committee in Cleveland. Kislyak is also present, along with other diplomats. Gordon and Page later admit to meeting with Kislyak, though they deny engaging in any inappropriate conversation on behalf of the Trump campaign. Phares later denies having partaken in the meeting with Kislyak.
Sessions speaks individually"}}">speaks individually with Kislyak at the same event. Sessions later claims he attended the event as a member of the Senate Armed Services Committee, not as a surrogate for the Trump campaign. But a later report finds Sessions spoke about the Trump campaign during his appearance. He also paid for the trip with political funds, not official congressional funding.
July 22 ― WikiLeaks releases emails hacked from the DNC’s server.
July 26 ― U.S. intelligence agencies reportedly tell the White House they have “high confidence” that the Russian government is responsible for the DNC hack.
July 27 ― Trump and his campaign team push back against claims Russia is trying to help him get elected.
“I don’t know anything about it,” he tells CBS Miami"}}">tells CBS Miami. “I can tell you, I think if I came up with that, they’d say, ‘Oh, it’s a conspiracy theory,’ it’s ridiculous. I mean I have nothing to do with Russia. I don’t have any jobs in Russia. I’m all over the world, but we’re not involved in Russia.”
Manafort later gives an interview to CBS in which he defends Trump’s claims that he has no ties to Russia.
“That’s what he said,” says Manafort. “That’s what ... that’s obviously what our position is.”
July 27 ― Trump holds a news conference, where he appears to make light of reports of Russian hacking by directly asking the Russians to track down additional Hillary Clinton emails.
“I will tell you this, Russia: If you’re listening, I hope you’re able to find the 30,000 emails that are missing,” Trump says. “I think you will probably be rewarded mightily by our press.”
Roger Stone, a renowned political provocateur, longtime Trump confidant and former adviser to Trump’s campaign, later says Russia would indeed have reason to hack Democratic presidential rival Clinton’s email.
July 31 ― In separate interviews, Trump"}}">Trump and Manafort"}}">Manafort both deny they were behind efforts to draft more Russia-friendly GOP platform language.
In August ― Manafort reportedly meets"}}">reportedly meets with Kilimnik again. This time, his trip reportedly attracts the attention of U.S. investigators. Kilimnik reportedly claims he partook in the effort to soften GOP platform language toward Ukraine.
Aug. 5 ― Assange claims WikiLeaks"}}">claims WikiLeaks is “working on” obtaining Trump’s tax returns. The organization later walks back that claim, calling it a joke.
Stone publishes a column in Breitbart News"}}">column in Breitbart News that accuses Clinton of manufacturing links between Russia and recent hacks.
Aug. 8 ― Stone claims to have communicated with Assange"}}">claims to have communicated with Assange.
“I actually have communicated with Assange,” he said. “I believe the next tranche of his documents pertain to the Clinton Foundation, but there’s no telling what the October surprise may be.”
Aug. 14 ― The New York Times reports"}}">reports that Manafort’s name was listed on a secret payment ledger from Yanukovych’s political party. The document shows more than $12 million earmarked for Manafort, though his lawyer denies that the payments were ever made.
That same day, Stone engages in a brief conversation"}}">engages in a brief conversation with the official Twitter account of Guccifer 2.0. Stone later admits to the exchange"}}">admits to the exchange but calls it “completely innocuous and perfunctory.”
Aug. 21 ― Stone predicts trouble for Clinton campaign manager John Podesta. Podesta’s email had already been hacked at the time, though WikiLeaks doesn’t release the messages until October.
Aug. 29 ― Manafort steps down as Trump’s campaign manager.
Sept. 1 ― Obama’s Treasury Department announces new sanctions against Russia related to Putin’s meddling in Ukraine.
Sept. 3-5 ― Obama and Putin attend the G-20 summit in Hangzhou, China.
Sept. 5 ― Obama and Putin have a tense, lengthy discussion about a potential cease-fire in Syria. Putin publicly calls on Obama to lift recent sanctions. Obama later says the two men directly discussed, seemingly for the first time, reports of Russian hacking targeting Democratic Party officials. Obama says that he told Putin to “cut it out.”
Sept. 7 ― Defense Secretary Ash Carter accuses Russia of sowing seeds of global instability and questions if Moscow is genuinely interested in finding an agreement on a cease-fire in Syria.
Trump later praises Putin on national TV. “[Putin] has very strong control over a country,” he says during NBC’s commander-in-chief forum with Clinton in New York. “Now, it’s a very different system, and I don’t happen to like that system. But certainly in that system he’s been a leader far more than our president has been a leader.”
Sept. 8. ― Sessions and Kislyak meet privately in his Senate office.
Trump’s vice presidential pick, Indiana Gov. Mike Pence, later agrees with Trump’s assessment of Putin’s strength as a leader. “I think it’s inarguable that Vladimir Putin has been a stronger leader in his country than Barack Obama has been in this country,” he tells CNN. “And that’s going to change the day that Donald Trump becomes president.”
The same day, Trump goes on RT, where he tells host Larry King that it was “probably unlikely” Russia was trying to interfere in the election. Democrats “are putting that out,” Trump claims.
Sept. 9 ― Secretary of State John F. Kerry meets with Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov in Geneva. They reach an agreement on a renewal of a cease-fire in Syria.
Sept. 26 ― Page announces he’s taking a leave of absence"}}">taking a leave of absence from the Trump campaign amid controversy surrounding his Russian ties.
Later that day, Trump uses the hacked DNC emails to attack Clinton at the first presidential debate. But he also pushes back against claims Russia is involved in the hacks.
“She’s saying Russia, Russia, Russia, but I don’t — maybe it was. I mean, it could be Russia, but it could also be China. It could also be lots of other people. It also could be somebody sitting on their bed that weighs 400 pounds, OK? You don’t know who broke into DNC.”
Oct. 6 ― Stone again teases an October surprise courtesy of WikiLeaks.
Oct. 7 ― WikiLeaks releases Podesta’s stolen emails. The dump comes hours after a 2005 recording surfaced of Trump making vulgar comments and bragging about sexually assaulting women.
Oct. 9 ― Trump and Clinton get into a heated exchange about WikiLeaks during the second presidential debate. Trump insists that Russia has nothing to do with it.
“She doesn’t know if it’s the Russians doing the hacking,” Trump says. “Maybe there is no hacking. But they always blame Russia. And the reason they blame Russia because they think they’re trying to tarnish me with Russia. I know nothing about Russia. I know — I know about Russia, but I know nothing about the inner workings of Russia. I don’t deal there. I have no businesses there. I have no loans from Russia.”
Oct. 10 ― Trump reads from leaked Clinton campaign emails at a campaign rally in Pennsylvania.
“I love WikiLeaks,” he tells supporters.
Peter Nicholls / Reuters
WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange draws praise from Trump after hacked Democratic campaign emails are released.
Oct. 11 ― Donald Trump Jr. delivers a paid speech at a Paris event hosted by allies of the Russian government who supported the Kremlin’s approach to the Syrian conflict. Trump’s appearance reportedly nets him at least $50,000"}}">reportedly nets him at least $50,000.
Oct. 12 ― Stone admits to having contact with WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange over hacked emails regarding the Clinton campaign.
“I do have a back-channel communication with Assange, because we have a good mutual friend,” Stone tells CBS Miami"}}">CBS Miami. “That friend travels back and forth from the United States to London and we talk. I had dinner with him last Monday.”
Stone says this communication doesn’t involve any advance notice about the release of the stolen emails or their content. He also denies"}}">denies that WikiLeaks is linked to the Russians.
Brendan McDermid / Reuters
Political adviser Roger Stone boasts of his connections to the founder of WikiLeaks in October.
Oct. 30 ― A jetliner owned by Rybolovlev, the Russian oligarch who paid Trump nearly $100 million for a Florida property in 2008, lands in Las Vegas, where Trump is campaigning. Days later, the same plane lands in Charlotte, North Carolina, around the time of Trump’s arrival at that airport. Both trips appear to be unusual for Rybolovlev’s aircraft. The White House later says nobody on the campaign was aware of this overlap and dismisses the timing of the trips as coincidence.
“For a press corps so obsessed with evidence, proof and feigning a general disgust at even the hint of conspiracy, this is pretty rich,” a Trump spokesman tells Business Insider"}}">tells Business Insider in March 2017.
Nov. 8 ― Trump defeats Clinton in the presidential election.
Nov. 18 ― Trump selects Flynn as his national security adviser.
Dec. 8 ― Page returns to Russia"}}">returns to Russia, where he claims to be huddling with “business leaders and thought leaders.
Dec. 12 ― During a presentation in Moscow"}}">presentation in Moscow, Page says he met with an “executive from Rosneft” to discuss sanctions. Page says he has no role in the Trump administration.
Mid-to-late December ― Flynn and Jared Kushner, a senior adviser to Trump and the president’s son-in-law, meet with Kislyak at Trump Tower"}}">meet with Kislyak at Trump Tower. Trump campaign officials claim they engaged in a general conversation, with the goal of “establish[ing] a line of communication” between the incoming administration and the Russian government.
Dec. 26 ― Moscow police find Oleg Erovinkin, a former KGB official linked to the dossier on Trump’s supposed ties to Russia, dead in the back seat of his car. Reports of his death don’t surface until a month later, fueling conspiracy theories revolving around a string of other Russian diplomats"}}">string of other Russian diplomats, including U.N. Ambassador Vitaly Churkin, who have died since November. Officials have not officially given a cause of death for Erovinkin, though local reports claimed it was a result of foul play.
Dec. 29 ― Flynn has multiple phone conversations with Kislyak to discuss sanctions handed down by Obama earlier in the day, which included the expulsion of suspected Russian intelligence operatives in response to meddling in the U.S. presidential election. Officials later say a review of the transcript"}}">review of the transcript didn’t reveal any criminal wrongdoing by Flynn.
Thomas Peter/Reuters
Meetings with Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak appear to slip Sen. Jeff Sessions’ mind during his Senate hearings.
Dec. 30 ― Trump applauds Putin’s decision not to retaliate against the Obama administration’s sanctions, overturning an earlier plan by Russia’s foreign minister to expel U.S. diplomatic staff from Moscow.
2017
Jan. 6 ― U.S. intelligence agencies release an unclassified report"}}">release an unclassified report concluding that Putin directed efforts to intervene in the U.S. presidential election with the goal of helping Trump win. The authors of the report argue that Russian spies hacked into DNC servers in July 2015 and maintained access for more than a year. They claim a Russian hacking agency “relayed material it acquired from the DNC and senior Democratic officials to WikiLeaks.”
Jan. 7 ― After denying Russia played a role in hacking or affected November’s elections results, Trump doubles down on insisting that his only goal is to improve U.S. relations with Russia.
Jan. 10 ― In sworn testimony during his confirmation hearing for attorney general, Sessions fails to disclose his meetings with Kislyak.
“I’m not aware of those activities,” Sessions tells Sen. Al Franken (D-Minn.) of reports of contacts between Trump campaign officials and the Russian envoy. “I have been called a surrogate at a time or two in that campaign, and I did not have communications with the Russians.”
Later that day, CNN and BuzzFeed publish reports on an unverified dossier compiled by former British intelligence agent Christopher Steele. The document contains provocative claims that people in Trump’s campaign were actively involved with Russian efforts to meddle in the election.
Jan. 11 ― Trump assails intelligence agencies on Twitter"}}">assails intelligence agencies on Twitter and accuses them of pushing a “fake” story about his campaign’s ties to Russia. He goes on to liken their alleged efforts to “Nazi Germany.”
Jan. 17 ― Trump again denies having any business dealings in Russia.
“I have no dealings with Russia,” he says at a news conference. “I have no deals that could happen in Russia, because we’ve stayed away. And I have no loans with Russia.”
Jan. 19 ― Manafort, Page and Stone are named in a New York Times report as targets of an investigation by U.S. intelligence and law enforcement agencies into the campaign’s ties with Russia.
Jan. 20 ― Trump is sworn in as 45th president of the United States.
Tom Williams via Getty Images
Donald Trump is inaugurated the day after three of his former aides are reported to be targets of an investigation into Russian ties.
Feb. 6 ― Michael Cohen, vice president of the Trump Organization and Trump’s personal lawyer, delivers Flynn a proposal"}}">delivers Flynn a proposal to lift U.S. sanctions on Russia and broker peace in Crimea. Felix Sater, who had previously pursued business in Moscow on Trump’s behalf, is also a party to the deal. The plan is reportedly crafted through back-channel communications and does not have official backing.
Feb. 8 ― Sessions wins Senate confirmation in a 52-47 vote, mostly along party lines.
Feb. 9 ― The Washington Post reports"}}">Washington Post reports that Flynn discussed U.S. sanctions against Russia in his previous conversations with Kislyak.
Feb. 13 ― Flynn steps down as national security adviser.
Feb. 14 ― The New York Times, citing “four current and former American officials,” reports"}}">reports that members of Trump’s campaign and other associates “had repeated contacts with senior Russian intelligence officials in the year before the election.”
Feb. 15 ― CNN, citing anonymous U.S. officials, reports"}}">reports that “high-level advisers close to then-presidential nominee Donald Trump were in constant communication during the campaign with Russians known to US intelligence.”
Feb. 16 ― Trump dismisses recent reports about his campaign’s contact with Russia as “fake news” and “a ruse.”
Stone denies having contact"}}">denies having contact with anyone from Russia or their intermediaries during the presidential campaign.
March 2 ― Sessions announces he will recuse himself from any Justice Department investigation into the Trump campaign’s potential ties to Russia, following reports that he’d failed to disclose meetings with Kislyak during his confirmation hearing.
Yuri Gripas / Reuters
U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions announces that he will recuse himself from any Justice Department investigation into Trump campaign contacts with Russia.
March 4 ― In a string of early-morning tweets, Trump accuses Obama of tapping his phones at Trump Tower the month before the election. The allegations, made with no substantiation, spark further questions about whether the president is among the targets of the Trump-Russia investigation.
March 5 ― Stone deletes tweet about his “back-channel communication” with Assange. He later speaks about the “mutual friend” with links to WikiLeaks but again denies that Assange is cooperating with the Russians.
March 9 ― White House press secretary Sean Spicer says Trump is not one of the targets of an investigation into the campaign’s Russia ties, after first appearing to suggest it was a possibility.
March 20 ― FBI Director James Comey appears at a House Intelligence Committee hearing, where he confirms that intelligence and law enforcement agencies are still investigating potential collusion between Trump’s campaign and Russia. Comey also directly refutes Trump’s wiretapping claim, saying he has no information to support the president’s allegations.
We’ll be updating this story as we get additional information. If you believe there’s an additional relevant date worth including on this timeline, please email it to scoop@huffingtonpost.com.
Do you have information you want to share with the Huffington Post? Here’s how.
Suggest a correction
Nick Wing Senior Viral Editor, The Huffington Post
MORE:
Donald Trump U.s. Presidential Elections Russia Vladimir Putin Jeff Sessions
Sign Your Name: Make Voter Registration Automatic
Target: American Lawmakers
We should be making it easier for people to vote, not harder. That's why voter registration should be automatic for every eligible citizen.
Sign our petition if you agree that voter registration should be automatic.
This petition is hosted by The Action Network. By adding your name, you are sharing your information with The Action Network, whose Privacy Policy (https://actionnetwork.org/privacy) applies.
Petition by
Progressive Turnout Project
Northbrook, Illinois
Sign This Petition
Not in the US?
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
You May Like5 Years From Now, You’ll Probably Wish You Grabbed These StocksThe Motley FoolOak Ridge, Tennessee: This Brilliant Company Is Disrupting a $200 Billion IndustryProvide Savings Insurance QuotesHiring a Handyman: The Best Solution for Your Small Home RepairsHomeAdvisorOak Ridge: This Meal Service is Cheaper Than Your Local StoreHome ChefThe amazing VA benefits not enough vets are claiming in TennesseeLendingTree Mortgage QuotesWondering which applications to move to the cloud?Microsoft
Around The WebPowered By ZergNet
How Trump Is Trying to Govern America Like an Internet TrollRollingstone.com
North Korea Threatens US With ‘Merciless’ AttacksNypost.com
School Destroys Betsy DeVos On Twitter After CriticismScarymommy.com
CONVERSATIONS
TRENDING
Trump Gives Evidence Of Being An Atheist!
Twitter Is Buzzing With Donald Trump ‘Space Alien’ Rumors
Reese Witherspoon Shows What Happens When You Give Your Kid A Hard-To-Spell Name
Jessica Chastain Shuts Down Bro Who Tried To Mansplain Women’s Health
Lipstick Under A Microscope Is Insanely Gorgeous, One Science Teacher Discovers
LendingTree
The Amazing VA Benefits Not Enough Vets Are Claiming
SUBSCRIBE TO & FOLLOW POLITICS
How will Trump’s administration impact you? Learn more
Newsletter
Everything We Know About Trumpland’s Ties To Russia, From Start To Finish
SUGGESTED FOR YOU
Germany Considers Fining Social Media Sites For Hate Speech, Fake News
Chris Evans Was Warned Not To Talk About Trump, But Does It Anyway
Scottish Leader Demands New Referendum On Independence
‘Blind’ Cat Dazzles Everyone After Opening His Stunning Eyes
Twitter Hilariously Burns Kellyanne Conway For Microwave Comment
WHAT’S HOT
Camera Catches 2-Year-Old Twins Having Epic Party After Bedtime
People Cancels Annual Correspondents’ Dinner Event In The Name Of Press Freedom
Mom Shares Postpartum Medical Struggles With Powerful Instagram
Asian ‘Iron Fist’ Actor Who Lost Lead To White Guy Gets Major Internet Love
Army Vet Who Served Two Tours In Afghanistan To Be Deported, Judge Rules
Suspected U.S. Airstrike Hits School Sheltering Displaced People In Syria
Stephen Colbert Tears Into The Trump Administration’s Paranoia
Nazi-Themed Trump Billboard To Stay Up As Long As He’s President, Owner Says
03/14/2017 07:00 am ET | Updated 1 day ago
Everything We Know About Trumpland’s Ties To Russia, From Start To Finish
It’s a convoluted history that raises a lot of questions.
By Nick Wing
What’s up with Donald Trump and Russia?
Depending on whom you ask, the answer to that question is either absolutely nothing or a scandal so huge it will lead to the president’s impeachment. So far, it’s unclear if either side is right. The truth may lie somewhere between the two extremes.
Trump’s camp has maintained that contact between the campaign and Russia was inconsequential and in some cases nonexistent, a claim that has proved untrue. We now know that members of Trump’s campaign met with Russian officials as the nation was apparently meddling in the U.S. presidential election with the goal of helping Trump win. If there’s any evidence of collusion between the president or his associates and Russia, however, it hasn’t been released.
Our timeline documents 30 years of Trump and his circle’s connections to Russia, which entered the spotlight in 2015 with the assembly of a campaign staff and platform that showed unprecedented levels of friendliness toward a historical adversary of the United States. The House Intelligence Committee will hold its first public hearing on the matter next week, which will hopefully provide further clarity about what all of this means, if anything.
1987
Trump makes his first documented trip to Russia ― then the Soviet Union ― where he explores expanding his hotel business in Moscow.
That same year, Trump outlines a plan to solve the issue of nuclear proliferation amid Cold War tensions. The solution, he tells journalist Ron Rosenbaum, is for the U.S. and the Soviet Union to join forces and use their nuclear and economic power to keep other nations from developing nukes and more broadly impose their will on the rest of the world.
“Most of those [pre-nuclear] countries are in one form or another dominated by the U.S. and the Soviet Union,” Trump says. “Between those two nations you have the power to dominate any of those countries. So we should use our power of economic retaliation and they use their powers of retaliation and between the two of us we will prevent the problem from happening.”
Ron Galella via Getty Images
Donald Trump celebrates publication of The Art of the Deal at the Trump Tower Atrium in New York City on Dec. 12, 1987. Earlier that year, he made his first reported trip to the Soviet Union and later outlined a U.S.-Russia plan on nuclear proliferation.
1988
Trump plans to meet with Mikhail Gorbachev in New York when the leader of the Soviet Union visits the United Nations. Trump reportedly wants"}}">reportedly wants to pitch his vision of a U.S.-Soviet nuclear alliance to Gorbachev.
Amid murmurs of Gorbachev’s scheduled trip to Trump Tower, Trump explains"}}">explains that his real estate prospects in Moscow didn’t work out.
“In the Soviet Union, you don’t own anything,” he says. “It’s hard to conjure up spending hundreds of millions of dollars on something and not own it.”
The meeting between Trump and Gorbachev ultimately falls through.
1996-1997
Trump resumes plans to expand his real estate empire in Moscow. Despite making several trips to the Russian capital, the project again fails to launch.
2005
Trump agrees to a licensing deal with development company Bayrock to build a hotel in Moscow. Bayrock’s founder is Tevfik Arif, a Kazakhstan-born former Soviet official. Trump reportedly puts Felix Sater"}}">reportedly puts Felix Sater, a Russian-born convicted felon with Mafia ties who now lives in the U.S., in charge of the project.
2006
Two of Trump’s children, Donald Trump Jr. and Ivanka, visit Moscow to meet with potential business partners. Sater claims Trump asked him to accompany"}}">asked him to accompany his children on the trip from New York to Russia, but the Trump Organization later said it was a coincidence that they were in Russia at the same time.
Over the next decade"}}">decade and beyond"}}">beyond, Trump attempts to distance himself from Sater, despite documents suggesting"}}">documents suggesting he played a substantial role at Trump Tower, including serving as a “senior adviser” to Trump.
Steve Carrera / Reuters
Donald Trump Jr., with his father and sister Ivanka, speaks to the press in Chicago on May 10, 2006, about plans for a Trump hotel and tower in Chicago. Donald Trump Jr. and Ivanka traveled to Moscow in 2006 to meet with potential business partners.
2007
Oct. 15 ― Trump praises Russian President Vladimir Putin in an interview with Larry King"}}">interview with Larry King.
“Look at Putin ― what he’s doing with Russia ― I mean, you know, what’s going on over there. I mean this guy has done ― whether you like him or don’t like him ― he’s doing a great job … in rebuilding the image of Russia and also rebuilding Russia period. Forget about image.”
Weeks before Trump’s comments, Putin had made a controversial play to maintain power by becoming Russia’s prime minister after serving two terms as president. He was elected president again in 2012.
2008
In July ― Trump sells a Palm Beach, Florida, estate to Russian oligarch Dmitry Rybolovlev for nearly $100 million. Trump had purchased in 2004 for less than half of that at a bankruptcy auction.
Sept. 15 ― Donald Trump Jr. tells a travel industry publication"}}">tells a travel industry publication that his organization has significant financial ties to Russia, which had led him to make at least a half-dozen trips there over the preceding 18 months.
“In terms of high-end product influx into the U.S., Russians make up a pretty disproportionate cross-section of a lot of our assets,” he says. “We see a lot of money pouring in from Russia. There’s indeed a lot of money coming for new-builds and resale reflecting a trend in the Russian economy and, of course, the weak dollar versus the ruble.”
But Trump’s son admits it’s been hard for them to get a foothold in the Russian market.
“As much as we want to take our business over there, Russia is just a different world,” he says. “t is a question of who knows who, whose brother is paying off who, etc. … It really is a scary place.”
2010
Oct. 26 ― Julian Assange of WikiLeaks teases a large-scale document dump"}}">teases a large-scale document dump supposedly detailing the shadowy inner workings of the Russian government. The release never happens.
Dec. 12 ― During an impromptu chat with Brian Kilmeade of Fox News, Trump calls WikiLeaks “disgraceful”"}}">calls WikiLeaks “disgraceful” and suggests there should be a “death penalty or something” for the perpetrators.
2011
Dec. 5 ― Trump expresses “respect” for Putin in his book Time to Get Tough.
“Putin has big plans for Russia. He wants to edge out its neighbors so that Russia can dominate oil supplies to all of Europe. Putin has also announced his grand vision: the creation of a ‘Eurasian Union’ made up of former Soviet nations that can dominate the region. I respect Putin and the Russians but cannot believe our leader allows them to get away with so much...Hats off to the Russians...[President Barack] Obama’s plan to have Russia stand up to Iran was a horrible failure that turned America into a laughingstock.”
2013
June 18 ― Trump tweets about the upcoming Miss Universe Pageant, which he owns:
Then he tries to make a playdate with Putin:
In August ― The editor-in-chief of the Kremlin-backed RT network reportedly visits Assange at the Ecuadorian Embassy in London, according to a report later released by U.S. intelligence agencies.
“They discussed renewing his broadcast contract with RT, according to Russian and Western media,” the 2017 report states. “Russian media subsequently announced that RT had become ‘the only Russian media company’ to partner with WikiLeaks and had received access to ‘new leaks of secret information.’ RT routinely gives Assange sympathetic coverage and provides him a platform to denounce the United States.”
Oct. 17 ― Trump tells late-night talk show host David Letterman that he has “a lot of business with the Russians.” He responds to Letterman’s quip about Russians being “commies” by calling them “smart” and “tough.” Trump says he had met Putin “once.”
Nov. 10 ― Trump returns from the Miss Universe Pageant, which was apparently an eye-opening trip.
He later tweets"}}">tweets that he plans to build a Trump Tower in Moscow.
2014
In February ― Troops aligned with Russia begin to invade and seize control of the Crimean peninsula in Ukraine.
March 17 ― After Putin officially annexes Crimea, Obama’s administration imposes personal sanctions on Russian officials for facilitating the incursion. Targeted individuals are banned from traveling to the U.S., and their U.S.-based financial assets are frozen.
Throughout 2014 ― Trump grants interviews to biographer Michael D’Antonio, who would go on to write The Truth About Trump. Trump brags about courting Russian clients to buy real estate at his properties in the U.S.
“I know the Russians better than anybody,” Trump tells D’Antonio, according to transcripts the author later provided to The New York Times.
2015
Feb. 25 ― Trump tells conservative radio host Hugh Hewitt he’ll release his tax returns"}}">he’ll release his tax returns if he decides to run for president.
“I would certainly show tax returns if it was necessary,” he says. “I have no objection to certainly showing tax returns.”
Trump never makes this disclosure, which experts say"}}">experts say would provide some clarity about the nature of his dealings in Russia.
June 16 ― Trump officially announces his bid for president.
July 20 ― Trump predicts"}}">predicts that he’d “get along very well with” Putin. Trump also notes that he’d had “major business” in Russia in the past and claims he’d “had a great relationship with the people of Russia.”
Sept. 20 ― Trump says he’s open to meeting"}}">open to meeting with Putin at the United Nations General Assembly. A few days earlier, the Trump Organization’s vice president, Michael Cohen, said it was a “better than likely chance” the two men would convene. A meeting is never confirmed.
Sept. 21 ― Trump describes his 2013 visit to Moscow"}}">describes his 2013 visit to Moscow in an interview with Hugh Hewitt.
“I was with the top-level people, both oligarchs and generals, and top-of-the-government people,” Trump says. “I can’t go further than that, but I will tell you that I met the top people, and the relationship was extraordinary. And we just don’t have relationships in this country. You know, relationship is very important, whether it’s congressmen or whether it’s senators, or, you know, whatever it may be. Relationship is a very important element, and we don’t have it in this country anymore.”
Sept. 29 ― Trump offers kind words to Putin"}}">offers kind words to Putin, telling Fox News’ Bill O’Reilly that the Russian president “is a nicer person than I am.”
Trump also claims Putin is a more effective leader than Obama.
“I will tell you that, in terms of leadership, he’s getting an A and our president is not doing so well,” he says.
Oct. 11 ― Trump continues to portray himself as a friend and acquaintance of Putin.
“I think the biggest thing we have is that we were on ‘60 Minutes’ together and we had fantastic ratings. One of your best-rated shows in a long time,” he jokes on CBS. “So that was good, right? So we were stable mates.”
Nov. 10 ― Trump repeats his claim about Putin and “60 Minutes” at a GOP debate but later clarifies that they never actually met during the taping of the show. Over the next few months, the Trump-Putin bromance continues to blossom, with both men regularly complimenting each other in public comments and appearances.
Dec. 10 ― Retired Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn, former director of the Defense Intelligence Agency, attends a high-profile gala"}}">attends a high-profile gala in Moscow hosted by RT. He’s reportedly paid $40,000 for the appearance, at which he sits near Putin.
Sputnik Photo Agency / Reuters
Retired Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn, left, sits with Russian President Vladimir Putin at an exhibition marking the 10th anniversary of the RT television channel in Moscow on Dec. 10, 2015.
2016
Feb. 9 ― Rex Tillerson, then-CEO of Exxon Mobil, in a speech"}}">in a speech at the University of Texas at Austin, says he has “a very close relationship” with Putin. Less than a year later, Tillerson is confirmed as Trump’s secretary of state.
March 21 ― Trump names Carter Page"}}">names Carter Page as a member of his campaign’s foreign policy team. Page is a former investment banker once based in Moscow and reportedly has ties to Russian energy magnates.
March 28 ― Trump brings on Paul Manafort as campaign manager to help him wrangle delegates in the GOP primary. Manafort had most recently served for more than a decade as senior adviser to former Ukrainian President Viktor F. Yanukovych, a Putin sympathizer who was ousted in 2014 and fled to Russia.
In April ― Manafort reportedly meets"}}">reportedly meets with Konstantin Kilimnik, a joint Russian-Ukrainian citizen who formerly worked as Manafort’s staffer in Washington, D.C. Kilimnik has suspected ties"}}">suspected ties to Russian intelligence officials.
April 27 ― Trump meets Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak before a foreign policy speech in Washington, D.C. Organizers claim the conversation between the two men was brief"}}">the conversation between the two men was brief and perhaps little more than a greeting. Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-Ala.), then a Trump campaign surrogate, reportedly also crosses paths with Kislyak"}}">crosses paths with Kislyak, though it’s unclear if they speak directly.
June 15 ― A hacker or hacker collective known as Guccifer 2.0 releases the first round of documents stolen from the Democratic National Committee. U.S. intelligence agencies later conclude that Russian-directed hackers are behind Guccifer’s actions.
July 7 ― Page delivers a speech at Moscow’s New Economic School criticizing U.S. policy toward Russia as reminiscent of Cold War tactics. He accuses the West of having a “hypocritical focus on ideas such as democratization, inequality, corruption and regime change.” The Trump campaign reportedly approves the trip"}}">reportedly approves the trip, which Page says he took as a private citizen.
An explosive, though unverified, intelligence dossier later claims that during the trip Igor Sechin, CEO of Rosneft, Russia’s state oil company, offers Page and associates a 19 percent stake in the company if he could help lift U.S. sanctions on Russia.
Pushing back against reports"}}">reports that he met with Putin confidants Sechin and Igor Diveykin, the Kremlin’s deputy chief of internal policy, Page says he had no contact with “sanctioned individuals.” He also denies discussing lifting economic sanctions or any further cooperation between the Russian government and the Trump campaign.
Sergei Karpukhin / Reuters
Carter Page, a member of the Trump campaign’s foreign policy team, delivers a speech in Moscow in 2016 in which he criticizes U.S. policy toward Russia.
July 18 ― Delegates at the Republican National Convenction adopt a party platform with wording supporting Ukraine’s sovereignty. Trump staffers reportedly work behind the scenes"}}">reportedly work behind the scenes to water down language that had called for “providing lethal defensive weapons” to Ukrainians and instead offer an amendment calling for the granting of “appropriate assistance.”
Trump national security adviser J.D. Gordon later says he advocated"}}">says he advocated for the softer platform language, which he says was consistent with Trump’s views on the matter.
July 20 ― Trump national security advisers Gordon, Page and Walid Phares reportedly attend a diplomacy event during the Republican National Committee in Cleveland. Kislyak is also present, along with other diplomats. Gordon and Page later admit to meeting with Kislyak, though they deny engaging in any inappropriate conversation on behalf of the Trump campaign. Phares later denies having partaken in the meeting with Kislyak.
Sessions speaks individually"}}">speaks individually with Kislyak at the same event. Sessions later claims he attended the event as a member of the Senate Armed Services Committee, not as a surrogate for the Trump campaign. But a later report finds Sessions spoke about the Trump campaign during his appearance. He also paid for the trip with political funds, not official congressional funding.
July 22 ― WikiLeaks releases emails hacked from the DNC’s server.
July 26 ― U.S. intelligence agencies reportedly tell the White House they have “high confidence” that the Russian government is responsible for the DNC hack.
July 27 ― Trump and his campaign team push back against claims Russia is trying to help him get elected.
“I don’t know anything about it,” he tells CBS Miami"}}">tells CBS Miami. “I can tell you, I think if I came up with that, they’d say, ‘Oh, it’s a conspiracy theory,’ it’s ridiculous. I mean I have nothing to do with Russia. I don’t have any jobs in Russia. I’m all over the world, but we’re not involved in Russia.”
Manafort later gives an interview to CBS in which he defends Trump’s claims that he has no ties to Russia.
“That’s what he said,” says Manafort. “That’s what ... that’s obviously what our position is.”
July 27 ― Trump holds a news conference, where he appears to make light of reports of Russian hacking by directly asking the Russians to track down additional Hillary Clinton emails.
“I will tell you this, Russia: If you’re listening, I hope you’re able to find the 30,000 emails that are missing,” Trump says. “I think you will probably be rewarded mightily by our press.”
Roger Stone, a renowned political provocateur, longtime Trump confidant and former adviser to Trump’s campaign, later says Russia would indeed have reason to hack Democratic presidential rival Clinton’s email.
July 31 ― In separate interviews, Trump"}}">Trump and Manafort"}}">Manafort both deny they were behind efforts to draft more Russia-friendly GOP platform language.
In August ― Manafort reportedly meets"}}">reportedly meets with Kilimnik again. This time, his trip reportedly attracts the attention of U.S. investigators. Kilimnik reportedly claims he partook in the effort to soften GOP platform language toward Ukraine.
Aug. 5 ― Assange claims WikiLeaks"}}">claims WikiLeaks is “working on” obtaining Trump’s tax returns. The organization later walks back that claim, calling it a joke.
Stone publishes a column in Breitbart News"}}">column in Breitbart News that accuses Clinton of manufacturing links between Russia and recent hacks.
Aug. 8 ― Stone claims to have communicated with Assange"}}">claims to have communicated with Assange.
“I actually have communicated with Assange,” he said. “I believe the next tranche of his documents pertain to the Clinton Foundation, but there’s no telling what the October surprise may be.”
Aug. 14 ― The New York Times reports"}}">reports that Manafort’s name was listed on a secret payment ledger from Yanukovych’s political party. The document shows more than $12 million earmarked for Manafort, though his lawyer denies that the payments were ever made.
That same day, Stone engages in a brief conversation"}}">engages in a brief conversation with the official Twitter account of Guccifer 2.0. Stone later admits to the exchange"}}">admits to the exchange but calls it “completely innocuous and perfunctory.”
Aug. 21 ― Stone predicts trouble for Clinton campaign manager John Podesta. Podesta’s email had already been hacked at the time, though WikiLeaks doesn’t release the messages until October.
Aug. 29 ― Manafort steps down as Trump’s campaign manager.
Sept. 1 ― Obama’s Treasury Department announces new sanctions against Russia related to Putin’s meddling in Ukraine.
Sept. 3-5 ― Obama and Putin attend the G-20 summit in Hangzhou, China.
Sept. 5 ― Obama and Putin have a tense, lengthy discussion about a potential cease-fire in Syria. Putin publicly calls on Obama to lift recent sanctions. Obama later says the two men directly discussed, seemingly for the first time, reports of Russian hacking targeting Democratic Party officials. Obama says that he told Putin to “cut it out.”
Sept. 7 ― Defense Secretary Ash Carter accuses Russia of sowing seeds of global instability and questions if Moscow is genuinely interested in finding an agreement on a cease-fire in Syria.
Trump later praises Putin on national TV. “[Putin] has very strong control over a country,” he says during NBC’s commander-in-chief forum with Clinton in New York. “Now, it’s a very different system, and I don’t happen to like that system. But certainly in that system he’s been a leader far more than our president has been a leader.”
Sept. 8. ― Sessions and Kislyak meet privately in his Senate office.
Trump’s vice presidential pick, Indiana Gov. Mike Pence, later agrees with Trump’s assessment of Putin’s strength as a leader. “I think it’s inarguable that Vladimir Putin has been a stronger leader in his country than Barack Obama has been in this country,” he tells CNN. “And that’s going to change the day that Donald Trump becomes president.”
The same day, Trump goes on RT, where he tells host Larry King that it was “probably unlikely” Russia was trying to interfere in the election. Democrats “are putting that out,” Trump claims.
Sept. 9 ― Secretary of State John F. Kerry meets with Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov in Geneva. They reach an agreement on a renewal of a cease-fire in Syria.
Sept. 26 ― Page announces he’s taking a leave of absence"}}">taking a leave of absence from the Trump campaign amid controversy surrounding his Russian ties.
Later that day, Trump uses the hacked DNC emails to attack Clinton at the first presidential debate. But he also pushes back against claims Russia is involved in the hacks.
“She’s saying Russia, Russia, Russia, but I don’t — maybe it was. I mean, it could be Russia, but it could also be China. It could also be lots of other people. It also could be somebody sitting on their bed that weighs 400 pounds, OK? You don’t know who broke into DNC.”
Oct. 6 ― Stone again teases an October surprise courtesy of WikiLeaks.
Oct. 7 ― WikiLeaks releases Podesta’s stolen emails. The dump comes hours after a 2005 recording surfaced of Trump making vulgar comments and bragging about sexually assaulting women.
Oct. 9 ― Trump and Clinton get into a heated exchange about WikiLeaks during the second presidential debate. Trump insists that Russia has nothing to do with it.
“She doesn’t know if it’s the Russians doing the hacking,” Trump says. “Maybe there is no hacking. But they always blame Russia. And the reason they blame Russia because they think they’re trying to tarnish me with Russia. I know nothing about Russia. I know — I know about Russia, but I know nothing about the inner workings of Russia. I don’t deal there. I have no businesses there. I have no loans from Russia.”
Oct. 10 ― Trump reads from leaked Clinton campaign emails at a campaign rally in Pennsylvania.
“I love WikiLeaks,” he tells supporters.
Peter Nicholls / Reuters
WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange draws praise from Trump after hacked Democratic campaign emails are released.
Oct. 11 ― Donald Trump Jr. delivers a paid speech at a Paris event hosted by allies of the Russian government who supported the Kremlin’s approach to the Syrian conflict. Trump’s appearance reportedly nets him at least $50,000"}}">reportedly nets him at least $50,000.
Oct. 12 ― Stone admits to having contact with WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange over hacked emails regarding the Clinton campaign.
“I do have a back-channel communication with Assange, because we have a good mutual friend,” Stone tells CBS Miami"}}">CBS Miami. “That friend travels back and forth from the United States to London and we talk. I had dinner with him last Monday.”
Stone says this communication doesn’t involve any advance notice about the release of the stolen emails or their content. He also denies"}}">denies that WikiLeaks is linked to the Russians.
Brendan McDermid / Reuters
Political adviser Roger Stone boasts of his connections to the founder of WikiLeaks in October.
Oct. 30 ― A jetliner owned by Rybolovlev, the Russian oligarch who paid Trump nearly $100 million for a Florida property in 2008, lands in Las Vegas, where Trump is campaigning. Days later, the same plane lands in Charlotte, North Carolina, around the time of Trump’s arrival at that airport. Both trips appear to be unusual for Rybolovlev’s aircraft. The White House later says nobody on the campaign was aware of this overlap and dismisses the timing of the trips as coincidence.
“For a press corps so obsessed with evidence, proof and feigning a general disgust at even the hint of conspiracy, this is pretty rich,” a Trump spokesman tells Business Insider"}}">tells Business Insider in March 2017.
Nov. 8 ― Trump defeats Clinton in the presidential election.
Nov. 18 ― Trump selects Flynn as his national security adviser.
Dec. 8 ― Page returns to Russia"}}">returns to Russia, where he claims to be huddling with “business leaders and thought leaders.
Dec. 12 ― During a presentation in Moscow"}}">presentation in Moscow, Page says he met with an “executive from Rosneft” to discuss sanctions. Page says he has no role in the Trump administration.
Mid-to-late December ― Flynn and Jared Kushner, a senior adviser to Trump and the president’s son-in-law, meet with Kislyak at Trump Tower"}}">meet with Kislyak at Trump Tower. Trump campaign officials claim they engaged in a general conversation, with the goal of “establish[ing] a line of communication” between the incoming administration and the Russian government.
Dec. 26 ― Moscow police find Oleg Erovinkin, a former KGB official linked to the dossier on Trump’s supposed ties to Russia, dead in the back seat of his car. Reports of his death don’t surface until a month later, fueling conspiracy theories revolving around a string of other Russian diplomats"}}">string of other Russian diplomats, including U.N. Ambassador Vitaly Churkin, who have died since November. Officials have not officially given a cause of death for Erovinkin, though local reports claimed it was a result of foul play.
Dec. 29 ― Flynn has multiple phone conversations with Kislyak to discuss sanctions handed down by Obama earlier in the day, which included the expulsion of suspected Russian intelligence operatives in response to meddling in the U.S. presidential election. Officials later say a review of the transcript"}}">review of the transcript didn’t reveal any criminal wrongdoing by Flynn.
Thomas Peter/Reuters
Meetings with Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak appear to slip Sen. Jeff Sessions’ mind during his Senate hearings.
Dec. 30 ― Trump applauds Putin’s decision not to retaliate against the Obama administration’s sanctions, overturning an earlier plan by Russia’s foreign minister to expel U.S. diplomatic staff from Moscow.
2017
Jan. 6 ― U.S. intelligence agencies release an unclassified report"}}">release an unclassified report concluding that Putin directed efforts to intervene in the U.S. presidential election with the goal of helping Trump win. The authors of the report argue that Russian spies hacked into DNC servers in July 2015 and maintained access for more than a year. They claim a Russian hacking agency “relayed material it acquired from the DNC and senior Democratic officials to WikiLeaks.”
Jan. 7 ― After denying Russia played a role in hacking or affected November’s elections results, Trump doubles down on insisting that his only goal is to improve U.S. relations with Russia.
Jan. 10 ― In sworn testimony during his confirmation hearing for attorney general, Sessions fails to disclose his meetings with Kislyak.
“I’m not aware of those activities,” Sessions tells Sen. Al Franken (D-Minn.) of reports of contacts between Trump campaign officials and the Russian envoy. “I have been called a surrogate at a time or two in that campaign, and I did not have communications with the Russians.”
Later that day, CNN and BuzzFeed publish reports on an unverified dossier compiled by former British intelligence agent Christopher Steele. The document contains provocative claims that people in Trump’s campaign were actively involved with Russian efforts to meddle in the election.
Jan. 11 ― Trump assails intelligence agencies on Twitter"}}">assails intelligence agencies on Twitter and accuses them of pushing a “fake” story about his campaign’s ties to Russia. He goes on to liken their alleged efforts to “Nazi Germany.”
Jan. 17 ― Trump again denies having any business dealings in Russia.
“I have no dealings with Russia,” he says at a news conference. “I have no deals that could happen in Russia, because we’ve stayed away. And I have no loans with Russia.”
Jan. 19 ― Manafort, Page and Stone are named in a New York Times report as targets of an investigation by U.S. intelligence and law enforcement agencies into the campaign’s ties with Russia.
Jan. 20 ― Trump is sworn in as 45th president of the United States.
Tom Williams via Getty Images
Donald Trump is inaugurated the day after three of his former aides are reported to be targets of an investigation into Russian ties.
Feb. 6 ― Michael Cohen, vice president of the Trump Organization and Trump’s personal lawyer, delivers Flynn a proposal"}}">delivers Flynn a proposal to lift U.S. sanctions on Russia and broker peace in Crimea. Felix Sater, who had previously pursued business in Moscow on Trump’s behalf, is also a party to the deal. The plan is reportedly crafted through back-channel communications and does not have official backing.
Feb. 8 ― Sessions wins Senate confirmation in a 52-47 vote, mostly along party lines.
Feb. 9 ― The Washington Post reports"}}">Washington Post reports that Flynn discussed U.S. sanctions against Russia in his previous conversations with Kislyak.
Feb. 13 ― Flynn steps down as national security adviser.
Feb. 14 ― The New York Times, citing “four current and former American officials,” reports"}}">reports that members of Trump’s campaign and other associates “had repeated contacts with senior Russian intelligence officials in the year before the election.”
Feb. 15 ― CNN, citing anonymous U.S. officials, reports"}}">reports that “high-level advisers close to then-presidential nominee Donald Trump were in constant communication during the campaign with Russians known to US intelligence.”
Feb. 16 ― Trump dismisses recent reports about his campaign’s contact with Russia as “fake news” and “a ruse.”
Stone denies having contact"}}">denies having contact with anyone from Russia or their intermediaries during the presidential campaign.
March 2 ― Sessions announces he will recuse himself from any Justice Department investigation into the Trump campaign’s potential ties to Russia, following reports that he’d failed to disclose meetings with Kislyak during his confirmation hearing.
Yuri Gripas / Reuters
U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions announces that he will recuse himself from any Justice Department investigation into Trump campaign contacts with Russia.
March 4 ― In a string of early-morning tweets, Trump accuses Obama of tapping his phones at Trump Tower the month before the election. The allegations, made with no substantiation, spark further questions about whether the president is among the targets of the Trump-Russia investigation.
March 5 ― Stone deletes tweet about his “back-channel communication” with Assange. He later speaks about the “mutual friend” with links to WikiLeaks but again denies that Assange is cooperating with the Russians.
March 9 ― White House press secretary Sean Spicer says Trump is not one of the targets of an investigation into the campaign’s Russia ties, after first appearing to suggest it was a possibility.
March 20 ― FBI Director James Comey appears at a House Intelligence Committee hearing, where he confirms that intelligence and law enforcement agencies are still investigating potential collusion between Trump’s campaign and Russia. Comey also directly refutes Trump’s wiretapping claim, saying he has no information to support the president’s allegations.
We’ll be updating this story as we get additional information. If you believe there’s an additional relevant date worth including on this timeline, please email it to scoop@huffingtonpost.com.
Do you have information you want to share with the Huffington Post? Here’s how.
Suggest a correction
Nick Wing Senior Viral Editor, The Huffington Post
MORE:
Donald Trump U.s. Presidential Elections Russia Vladimir Putin Jeff Sessions
Sign Your Name: Make Voter Registration Automatic
Target: American Lawmakers
We should be making it easier for people to vote, not harder. That's why voter registration should be automatic for every eligible citizen.
Sign our petition if you agree that voter registration should be automatic.
This petition is hosted by The Action Network. By adding your name, you are sharing your information with The Action Network, whose Privacy Policy (https://actionnetwork.org/privacy) applies.
Petition by
Progressive Turnout Project
Northbrook, Illinois
Sign This Petition
Not in the US?
- You may receive updates from Progressive Turnout Project, the creator of this petition.
- Edit Subscription Preferences
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
You May Like5 Years From Now, You’ll Probably Wish You Grabbed These StocksThe Motley FoolOak Ridge, Tennessee: This Brilliant Company Is Disrupting a $200 Billion IndustryProvide Savings Insurance QuotesHiring a Handyman: The Best Solution for Your Small Home RepairsHomeAdvisorOak Ridge: This Meal Service is Cheaper Than Your Local StoreHome ChefThe amazing VA benefits not enough vets are claiming in TennesseeLendingTree Mortgage QuotesWondering which applications to move to the cloud?Microsoft
Around The WebPowered By ZergNet
How Trump Is Trying to Govern America Like an Internet TrollRollingstone.com
North Korea Threatens US With ‘Merciless’ AttacksNypost.com
School Destroys Betsy DeVos On Twitter After CriticismScarymommy.com
CONVERSATIONS
TRENDING
Trump Gives Evidence Of Being An Atheist!
Twitter Is Buzzing With Donald Trump ‘Space Alien’ Rumors
Reese Witherspoon Shows What Happens When You Give Your Kid A Hard-To-Spell Name
Jessica Chastain Shuts Down Bro Who Tried To Mansplain Women’s Health
Lipstick Under A Microscope Is Insanely Gorgeous, One Science Teacher Discovers
LendingTree
The Amazing VA Benefits Not Enough Vets Are Claiming
SUBSCRIBE TO & FOLLOW POLITICS
How will Trump’s administration impact you? Learn more
Newsletter
Everything We Know About Trumpland’s Ties To Russia, From Start To Finish
SUGGESTED FOR YOU
Germany Considers Fining Social Media Sites For Hate Speech, Fake News
Chris Evans Was Warned Not To Talk About Trump, But Does It Anyway
Scottish Leader Demands New Referendum On Independence
‘Blind’ Cat Dazzles Everyone After Opening His Stunning Eyes
Twitter Hilariously Burns Kellyanne Conway For Microwave Comment
WHAT’S HOT
Camera Catches 2-Year-Old Twins Having Epic Party After Bedtime
People Cancels Annual Correspondents’ Dinner Event In The Name Of Press Freedom
Mom Shares Postpartum Medical Struggles With Powerful Instagram
Asian ‘Iron Fist’ Actor Who Lost Lead To White Guy Gets Major Internet Love
Army Vet Who Served Two Tours In Afghanistan To Be Deported, Judge Rules
Suspected U.S. Airstrike Hits School Sheltering Displaced People In Syria
Stephen Colbert Tears Into The Trump Administration’s Paranoia
Nazi-Themed Trump Billboard To Stay Up As Long As He’s President, Owner Says
