Well they were gifted the 1984 title. There were more deserving teams than them. They are far below the choices that either Big 10 or SEC make. Theoretically BYU fits the mold of the PAC. BYU would jump at that chance especially if Utah stays. This is one team Big 12 needs to work on, Utah. BYU will either stay Big 12 or jump to weaker PAC. Depends on Utah.Let’s be more observant here. BYU was not in a P5 for reasons that aren’t typical. First, they refused to play on Sundays. While that’s ok in college football, it’s not in the other major sports like basketball. Secondly, they were the Mormon version of ND whereas they wanted to be independent and were independent for a bit. Thirdly, their students are required to go on missions that last a few years. Fourthly, they have their own network. And lastly, their geographical location was not ideal outside of the Pac12, and that conference didn’t really like the mormon thing as it didn’t match the West Coast culture. Remember, BYU won a NC in 1984 and they’ve been very good in their history. They really are, only in my opinion, a sleeping giant. At the very least, they should be competitive in the Big12.
The title given to them in 1984 by beating a 6-5 Michigan in the Holiday Bowl 24-17.
BYU 13-0 (with the teams they played they probably don't make current playoffs)
Pitt 3-7-1
Baylor 5-6
Tulsa 6-5
Hawaii 7-4 (5-2) (2nd place behind BYU in WAC)
Colorado State 3-8
Wyoming 6-6
Air Force 8-4
New Mexico 4-8
UTEP 2-9
San Diego State 4-7-1
Utah 6-5-1
Utah State 1-10
Team that should have won was #4 Washington 11-1 who beat #2 Oklahoma.